You and your partner built the practice together. You share staff, equipment, a lease, and maybe a bank loan.
Now picture this: your partner dies suddenly at 52. Their spouse inherits their shares. The spouse isn’t a dentist, can’t treat patients, and needs income. You need control of the practice and can’t write a seven-figure cheque.
A buy-sell agreement, properly funded, settles all of this in advance. Yet many co-owned dental and medical practices in Canada either don’t have one or have one with no money behind it.
Why Group Practices Are More Exposed Than Most Businesses
In an ordinary business, a widow or widower can stay on as a passive shareholder for years. A professional corporation doesn’t work that way.
Provincial colleges require that voting shares of a medical or dental PC be held by licensed members. When a practitioner dies, their estate can usually act only for an interim period while the shares are sold or the corporation is restructured. The exact window and process depend on your college.
That creates pressure on everyone:
- The family needs a fair price, fast, without a fire sale.
- The surviving partner needs to buy the shares, often with no spare cash.
- The practice loses value every week that patients and staff feel uncertain.
A buy-sell agreement sets the price formula, the triggers, and the funding now, while everyone is healthy and on good terms.
What a Good Agreement Covers
At minimum, your shareholders’ agreement or partnership agreement should spell out:
- Triggers: death, long-term disability, loss of licence, retirement, and marital breakdown.
- Valuation: a formula or annual agreed value, with a process for updates. A stale value from 2017 helps no one.
- Obligation: whether the purchase is mandatory or optional for each trigger.
- Funding: where the money comes from, and how much.
- Disability definition: what “disabled” means, for how long, and how it lines up with any insurance policy.
Four Ways to Fund the Death Trigger With Life Insurance
Life insurance is the usual way to fund a buy-out on death, because the money arrives exactly when it’s needed. How the policy is owned matters a great deal for tax.
1. Criss-cross (personally owned). Each partner owns a policy on the other and pays with personal after-tax dollars. On death, the survivor uses the tax-free benefit to buy the shares. It’s simple, but premiums cost more because they’re paid from personal income, and it gets awkward when partners are very different ages or there are more than two owners.
2. Corporate redemption. The corporation owns policies on each shareholder. On death, it collects the benefit, credits most of it to the Capital Dividend Account, and buys back the deceased’s shares from the estate. Premiums are paid with lower-taxed corporate dollars. This works most naturally when all partners own one corporation together.
3. Promissory note. The surviving partner buys the shares from the estate with a promissory note. The corporation then pays the survivor a tax-free capital dividend from the insurance proceeds, which the survivor uses to pay off the note. The survivor also ends up with a higher cost base in the shares. This method must be written into the agreement in advance. It can’t be bolted on after a death.
4. Hybrid. A blend of redemption and purchase that tries to balance tax for both the estate and the survivor. Your accountant models the split.
A note on the stop-loss rules. When shares are redeemed using capital dividends, the Income Tax Act can limit how much of the estate’s loss the estate can carry back to the deceased’s final tax return. That can leave a tax bill where the family expected none. Older agreements may have grandfathered treatment. This is one of the main reasons the funding method should be chosen with your accountant and lawyer, not just picked from a brochure.
The Disability Gap Most Practices Ignore
A partner is far more likely to become disabled before 65 than to die. Disability is also the messier trigger. A partner who can’t practise still owns half the clinic and still needs income.
Three things to know:
Personal disability insurance won’t fund a buy-out. Your own policy replaces your income. Overhead expense insurance covers the practice’s bills. Neither one buys your partner’s shares.
Disability buy-sell insurance exists, but it’s scarce. Recent industry reports show only two Canadian insurers, Canada Life and RBC Insurance, still offer it. Elimination periods are long, typically 12 to 24 months, so the buy-out only happens if the disability is truly lasting. RBC’s product also requires every insured partner to have the same elimination period.
Critical illness insurance can fill part of the gap. A critical illness policy pays a lump sum after a covered diagnosis, such as cancer, heart attack or stroke, and a short survival period. Some practices use it to fund part of a buy-out, or to give the partners cash while they decide what to do. Critical illness and disability aren’t the same thing, so the agreement needs to say clearly which event triggers which obligation.
A Quick Checklist for Co-Owners
- Do we have a signed agreement, and when was it last reviewed?
- Does the valuation reflect what the practice is worth today?
- Is the insurance amount still equal to each partner’s share value?
- Who owns the policies, and does that match the method in the agreement?
- Does our disability definition match our policy’s definition and elimination period?
- Have our accountant and lawyer reviewed the stop-loss impact?
- Do our wills deal with the PC shares in a way that works with the agreement?
A Research-Backed Note on Picking Managers
Surviving partners and estates often end up with a large lump sum to invest. S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA Canada report found that 93.4% of actively managed Canadian equity funds trailed the S&P/TSX Composite in 2025. Its companion persistence study found that top-ranked funds rarely stay on top, holding their rank less often than chance would predict. That matches Eugene Fama’s research: past winners mostly reflect luck. For a buy-out payment, a low-cost, broadly diversified portfolio is usually more reliable than the fund that topped last year’s list.
The Bottom Line
A buy-sell agreement without funding is a promise nobody can keep. For dentists and physicians in group practices, college ownership rules make the clock even tighter.
Settle the price, choose the right funding method with your advisers, and don’t forget the disability trigger. Your partner’s family, your patients and your own future will all be better protected.
Co-own a practice? Book a private consultation with the team at financialadvise.ca. We’ll review your agreement’s funding alongside your accountant and lawyer and show you where the gaps are. You can contact us at 587 718 8001
This article is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, insurance, or personalized financial advice. Tax rules, contribution limits, insurance product features, and provincial regulatory requirements referenced above reflect our understanding as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. Every individual’s financial, tax, and corporate situation is different — strategies discussed here should not be implemented without first consulting a qualified accountant, tax lawyer, licensed insurance advisor, and, where applicable, your provincial regulatory college. Mehan Private Wealth does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of this information to your specific circumstances and accepts no liability for decisions made in reliance on it.
This content is for general information purposes only and is not tax, legal, or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional before acting on any strategy discussed.
Leave A Comment